Problem
Allen-Bradley 1769-HSC can be configured from 1 to 4 counters. But the inputs assigned to each counter is not very clear.
Solution
Figure 2.1 in 1769-HSC user manual page 2-5 shows:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/30194/30194ddde5d7ca50e9da811a5f2d2d60228d4c94" alt="1769-HSC Counter Input Assigment"
This is the best explanation of which inputs assigned to which 1769-HSC counter under various configuration.